The Riemann Hypothesis, Room by RoomRiemann, Room by Room
3Room 3 of 9Read by Siegel, 1932

The calculation sheets

Primzahlen

Map. You're in room 3, Calculation sheets.
Cod. Ms. B. Riemann 3 · Primzahlen
½ + 14.1347… i
21.0220… 25.0108…
ζ(½ + it) = Σ n^(−½−it) + …
„nach einigen flüchtigen vergeblichen Versuchen“
Siegel 1932 · Über Riemanns Nachlaß
Briefentwürfe
Set in type, not a scan.

The lights are off in here.

0 of 7 found
All 7 labels, without the torch
  1. Cod. Ms. B. Riemann 3 · Primzahlen The folder. That's the library's catalogue number for it, and it's labelled "Primzahlen", prime numbers.
  2. ½ + 14.1347… i The first zero. Siegel's reading showed Riemann had checked by hand that the first few zeros sit on the line. The digits shown are modern values.
  3. 21.0220… 25.0108… The next two. Gabcke describes "a lot of calculation sheets in order to determine the first zeros". These digits are modern values too.
  4. ζ(½ + it) = Σ n^(−½−it) + … A fast way to compute zeta on the line. Riemann worked it out in these papers. Siegel published it in 1932, and now it carries both their names: the Riemann-Siegel formula.
  5. „nach einigen flüchtigen vergeblichen Versuchen“ The printed paper says he put the proof aside "after some quick unsuccessful attempts". The sheets show how much arithmetic he did anyway.
  6. Siegel 1932 · Über Riemanns Nachlaß Carl Ludwig Siegel read the notes about seventy years after Riemann died, and published what he found in 1932.
  7. Briefentwürfe Drafts of letters, filed in with the zeros.
Cod. Ms. B. Riemann 3
Primzahlen
Catalogue no.
Cod. Ms. B. Riemann 3
Title
Primzahlen
Held
SUB Göttingen
Inside
Riemann-Siegel derivation, calculation sheets for the first zeros, letter drafts
Read by
Carl Ludwig Siegel, 1932

He did the arithmetic first

Riemann's paper reads like a hunch. He wrote that it was “very likely” the zeros were all on the line, and that he'd put the proof aside after a few quick attempts.

In 1932 Carl Ludwig Siegel went through the papers Göttingen kept after Riemann died. In this folder he found pages of hard calculation. Riemann had worked out the first zeros by hand before he made his guess, and he'd derived a fast way to compute zeta on the line.

Each zero is a note

In Riemann's explicit formula the count of primes is a smooth curve minus one wave per zero, and the zero's height sets the wave's pitch. Switch the waves on below and the staircase comes back. I think it's the most awesome thing on this floor.

There's more in the Run Data Run Deep Dive.

The piano roll

Zoom: 17 to 32
Zeros on
0
Biggest miss
0.00
Clicks on primes
0 of 0

Press play to sweep from 2 to 100. Each click flashes on the staircase too.

The first 30 zeros, one row each. Low notes at the top.

Ink is the true count of primes, and the dashed line is the smooth part alone. Red is the rebuild from the zeros you've switched on. With ten zeros it leans into the steps. With a hundred it's nearly square. The inset zooms on 17 to 31, where the corners sharpen. Play the chord and the waves only line up at primes, so that's where it clicks.