The fair copy
- Object
- Fair copy of the 1859 paper
- Hand
- Alfred Clebsch
- Identified by
- Wolfgang Gabcke, 2015
- Made for
- Probably the printers of the 1876 collected works
- Held
- SUB Göttingen, Riemann papers
No photo. It lives in a library in Göttingen.
Object not on view
These six pages are often shown as Riemann’s manuscript. Wolfgang Gabcke showed in 2015 that they aren’t in Riemann’s hand. Alfred Clebsch wrote them out, probably as the copy the printers set the 1876 collected works from.
The pages are about one function, zeta, and the places where it equals zero. You can play with both below.
There's more in the Run Data Run Deep Dive.
A sum that knows the primes
Start with 1 + 1/2s + 1/3s + 1/4s and keep going. That sum is the zeta function, ζ(s). At s = 2 it creeps up on π²/6, about 1.645. Euler worked on this series in the 1730s. At s = 1 the sum never stops growing.
Euler’s product
Euler also proved the same sum equals a product with one factor for every prime:
1/(1 − 2−s) × 1/(1 − 3−s) × 1/(1 − 5−s) × …
Multiply it out and every whole number turns up once, because every whole number splits into primes in only one way. That’s why zeta knows where the primes are.
- Sum of the first 6 terms
- 1.491389
- Product over the 3 primes up to 6
- 1.562500
- Zeta at this s
- 1.644934
Both creep up on π²/6. The product gets there faster, using only the primes.
Ink is the sum, one term at a time. Yellow is Euler’s product over the primes up to N. The cross is the true value of zeta.
Riemann fed it complex numbers
A complex number has two parts, so it’s a point on a flat map: the real part runs across and the imaginary part runs up. The sum only works when the real part is above 1. Riemann extended zeta to the whole map, except the point s = 1, where it blows up.
On the map below, colour is the direction of ζ(s) and brightness is its size. Where every colour meets in a dark point, zeta is zero.
Zeros, the strip and the line
Zeta is zero at −2, −4, −6 and every negative even number. Those are easy to show, so they’re called the trivial zeros. Every other zero is known to sit in the critical strip, where the real part is between 0 and 1.
Riemann guessed they all sit on the middle of it, the critical line where the real part is ½. The first one is at ½ + 14.134725i. Nobody can rule out one at 0.499.
Drawn to scale.
Dashed lines mark the strip. The solid line is where the real part is ½. Each pin is a zero.